Overall rating: 4.9 / 5 from 622 reviews.
The best peanut butter, hands down!!! No other comes even close. Since I've discovered Homeplate peanut butter, I've never eaten any other and order it on line often. The price is reasonable and delivery is quick. Try it, you'll love it - guaranteed!
Love the honey!!! Just pure ingredients
Your Peanut butter is the bestest Paul
This Peanut butter is the best ever. Dont buy the other imposters. You will make this peanut butter, be it crunchy or creamy your only choice. Best on the planet. Paul
Championship breakfast! Homeplate is the PB king, and I've tried them all!
Simply the best peanut butter out there! I enjoy the honey peanut butter.
It's the best peanut butter ever. 🥜
Incredibly disappointed all 3 jars have use by/ fresh dates of 19 December 2025, especially having waited for 6 weeks 0 availability. Were you out of stock or being managed poorly?
Homeplate peanut butter is clearly the best peanut butter ever
This is me scraping the bottle to get it all, because it's so good.
Best peanut butter on the market, by far! Also, I’m diabetic and it doesn’t spike my blood sugar!
Home plate!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Always the best taste
Absolutley my favorite peanut butter. Simple ingredients. Great taste. The only brand I buy
Best camping food ever!!
Great Great peanut butter
Always fantastic. Creamy and delicious. Best peanut butter. Try it once and won't buy another. Paul
We love it! Oh my goodness. It’s our favorite peanut butter ever. It tastes just like peanuts at a baseball game!
We had a local store that carried Creamy and Crunchy but have been out of stock forever. So I found the mixed pack…. Honey is my new favorite! No matter the flavor, this is the best peanut butter I have ever had!
Love the crunchy.
It has been such a disappointment to revisit the peanut butter brands I enjoyed growing up. They just don't taste good. And then I found HOMEPLATE with its real peanut flavor and perfect consistency. I am a big fan of both the creamy and chunky varieties. Have not tried the honey.
I love the texture and flavor of the crunchy peanut butter. I will be ordering more once my 6 pack starts running low
Best Damn Peanut Butter Ever!
My favorite way to eat my favorite peanut butter is by adding Honey Homeplate and Crunchy Homeplate PB to my oatmeal and add blueberries, bananas, and other types of berries.
Delicious!
This honey peanut butter is so good! This is the first honey peanut butter we haven’t had to add extra honey to. You can really taste the honey flavor. When I couldn’t find it in my local Fry’s (Kroger) anymore, I ordered online. Wish it came in bigger jars!
Love this peanut butter. It is the best one i have found. I have been ordering it for months between my grocery store, then amazon and now directly through you. :)
What's wrong with this picture?
Not only do I eat HomePlate peanut butter by the spoonful, I keep a jar in my car!
Love it
Love it straight from the jar, watching the ball game with my cat!
as usual, best way to eat! one spoon (large), one jar of HomePlate!
I love this peanut butter I’ve tried many brands and home plate is by far the best
I started buying this brand in the grocery store. It got increasingly hard to find but I searched for it because the crunchy had so many crushed peanuts. More than any other brand. After I was no longer able to find it in stores. I began to order it online. Lately I have noticed changes in the product. The crunchy seems to be less oacjed with peanuts and the oil separates in the jar so it has to be stirred. Unfortunately the seal on the jar leaks and the jars, box and packing material are an oily mess when it arrives. This has happened multiple times.
We liked the peanut butter alot and it's good quality
My absolute favorite peanut butter.!!!Glad I can order online as there are no stores near me that sell it. My only issue with buying online is that the natural oil from the jars leaked a little and saturated two of the bottles on the outside. Just made them kinda sticky. Maybe they can be packaged differently to prevent this. BUT STILL THE MOST DELICIOUS PEANUT BUTTER AROUND!!!!
Really fake mouse, but really GREAT peanut butter!
The absolute BEST peanut butter I've ever eaten! 😍
I'd love to use the biggest spoon, but the jar is too small!
Everyone here, I mean everyone, loves HomePlate!
Delicious! Hard to stop eating it.
Overall rating: 4.9 / 5 from 622 reviews.
The best peanut butter, hands down!!! No other comes even close. Since I've discovered Homeplate peanut butter, I've never eaten any other and order it on line often. The price is reasonable and delivery is quick. Try it, you'll love it - guaranteed!
Love the honey!!! Just pure ingredients
Your Peanut butter is the bestest Paul
This Peanut butter is the best ever. Dont buy the other imposters. You will make this peanut butter, be it crunchy or creamy your only choice. Best on the planet. Paul
Championship breakfast! Homeplate is the PB king, and I've tried them all!
Simply the best peanut butter out there! I enjoy the honey peanut butter.
It's the best peanut butter ever. 🥜
Incredibly disappointed all 3 jars have use by/ fresh dates of 19 December 2025, especially having waited for 6 weeks 0 availability. Were you out of stock or being managed poorly?
Homeplate peanut butter is clearly the best peanut butter ever
This is me scraping the bottle to get it all, because it's so good.
Best peanut butter on the market, by far! Also, I’m diabetic and it doesn’t spike my blood sugar!
Home plate!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Always the best taste
Absolutley my favorite peanut butter. Simple ingredients. Great taste. The only brand I buy
Best camping food ever!!
Great Great peanut butter
Always fantastic. Creamy and delicious. Best peanut butter. Try it once and won't buy another. Paul
We love it! Oh my goodness. It’s our favorite peanut butter ever. It tastes just like peanuts at a baseball game!
We had a local store that carried Creamy and Crunchy but have been out of stock forever. So I found the mixed pack…. Honey is my new favorite! No matter the flavor, this is the best peanut butter I have ever had!
Love the crunchy.
It has been such a disappointment to revisit the peanut butter brands I enjoyed growing up. They just don't taste good. And then I found HOMEPLATE with its real peanut flavor and perfect consistency. I am a big fan of both the creamy and chunky varieties. Have not tried the honey.
I love the texture and flavor of the crunchy peanut butter. I will be ordering more once my 6 pack starts running low
Best Damn Peanut Butter Ever!
My favorite way to eat my favorite peanut butter is by adding Honey Homeplate and Crunchy Homeplate PB to my oatmeal and add blueberries, bananas, and other types of berries.
Delicious!
This honey peanut butter is so good! This is the first honey peanut butter we haven’t had to add extra honey to. You can really taste the honey flavor. When I couldn’t find it in my local Fry’s (Kroger) anymore, I ordered online. Wish it came in bigger jars!
Love this peanut butter. It is the best one i have found. I have been ordering it for months between my grocery store, then amazon and now directly through you. :)
What's wrong with this picture?
Not only do I eat HomePlate peanut butter by the spoonful, I keep a jar in my car!
Love it
Love it straight from the jar, watching the ball game with my cat!
as usual, best way to eat! one spoon (large), one jar of HomePlate!
I love this peanut butter I’ve tried many brands and home plate is by far the best
I started buying this brand in the grocery store. It got increasingly hard to find but I searched for it because the crunchy had so many crushed peanuts. More than any other brand. After I was no longer able to find it in stores. I began to order it online. Lately I have noticed changes in the product. The crunchy seems to be less oacjed with peanuts and the oil separates in the jar so it has to be stirred. Unfortunately the seal on the jar leaks and the jars, box and packing material are an oily mess when it arrives. This has happened multiple times.
We liked the peanut butter alot and it's good quality
My absolute favorite peanut butter.!!!Glad I can order online as there are no stores near me that sell it. My only issue with buying online is that the natural oil from the jars leaked a little and saturated two of the bottles on the outside. Just made them kinda sticky. Maybe they can be packaged differently to prevent this. BUT STILL THE MOST DELICIOUS PEANUT BUTTER AROUND!!!!
Really fake mouse, but really GREAT peanut butter!
The absolute BEST peanut butter I've ever eaten! 😍
I'd love to use the biggest spoon, but the jar is too small!
Everyone here, I mean everyone, loves HomePlate!
Delicious! Hard to stop eating it.
